Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Listening With Both Ears
He sat there, slumped in his chair, rapping his pencil on the edge of the desk to the beat of the music blaring from his Walkman headphones. Even I could hear it at the front of the room. I looked at the seating chart the teacher had left for me, the substitute teacher for the day. My suspicions were affirmed; he was in the wrong seat. He glared at me ... the challenge in his eyes was unmistakable.

I pointed to my ears, motioning to him to turn down the volume and remove the headphones. The pencil stopped rapping as he sullenly yanked the headphones down to his neck.

"Yah, what?"

"I believe you're in the wrong seat." I hated this. I didn't believe in seating plans any more than he did.

"Well, I wanna sit here today."

"Ok, let's make a deal. I see you didn't bring any books, which will make it difficult for you to do the assignment, but other people around you are working. So, you can sit there as long as you don't bother anyone."

I glanced at the certifiable ‘class geek' to his right, and heard the stifled giggles of the two cute blondes sitting behind him. A disaster in the making; I could smell it. "Is that a deal?"

"Yeah, ok."

The headphones were back on in an instant, and the pencil began rapping. It was quiet for all of three minutes as other students hunched over their books, chewing pencils and gum at the same time, or anxiously clicking their pens. What agony ... a class in weather, for crying out loud, with the toughest kids in the school.

Then it started. He poked the ‘geek’ in the arm with his pencil, not the eraser but the lead, a couple sharp jabs, and the blondes giggled behind their hands. The ‘geek’ flinched and moved his chair a little more to his right. Another jab. Ah, defiant one! He knew I saw and the gauntlet was once again thrown down.

I pointed at my ears; the headphones came off.

"What?"

"We had a deal. You just broke it. Go back to your regular seat." I understood why the teacher had placed him in the last possible seat at the back of the room, but it hardly seemed a solution to me.

"I wanna sit here. I'm not going … and you can't make me."

Now this kid - this kid was folded into his chair. I knew he wasn't a small person, and I also knew he was older than the typical age for the "you can't make me" challenge.

I walked over to stand beside his chair. He stood up; he was at least two feet taller than I. You know the words that crossed my mind, "oh, s...!" And though I hated to do it, it felt like a cop out, I pulled the ace card every substitute teacher carries up her sleeve.

"Ok ... I'll give you a choice. You can either go back to your own seat, or you can go out the door, take a left and then a right, and visit the vice-principal's office. But before you choose, I have a question for you. How many times have you already been there this week?"

Silence. The whole room, even the clock, was watching. He stared at me, then at the floor.

And then he spun around, shuffling his feet loudly on the linoleum, and threw himself into the seat at the back of the room. The chair tipped back and then rocked forward ... slam! Up went the volume on the Walkman. I had won ... or had I? I felt awful. He was way back there, a sullen satellite pushed to the edge of a world he could not enter.

I waited a few minutes for the others to turn back to their work, and I walked quietly to once again stand beside his chair. Again I motioned to my ears and slowly the headphones came off.

"What's your story?" I asked quietly.

He looked at me blankly. "What d'you mean, 'what's my story'?" There was an unmistakable edge of sarcasm.

"Why are you sitting back here? You don't like it here very much, do you? I mean, this school. How long have you been here?"

"Since January." It was March.

"Where were you before?"

"I've been in three schools this year. My parents moved so I could come to this one."

"What happened at the other schools?"

"I got kicked out."

"What for?"

"Fencing." Stolen goods ... if you can't fit in and be noticed for something good ....

"What do your parents think?"

"They don't care."

"Well, fencing; that's something.” Long pause. “You know, I feel sorry for you."

His eyes narrowed. "Sorry. What do you feel sorry for me for?"

"I feel sorry for you because it's hard to fit in a new school. It's hard to make friends. And sometimes you don't have any and that's lonely. I have a feeling you're very bright ... really smart and creative. If you can figure out how to fence, and I know you've been doing it for a while, you're smart and you could do anything. Public schools aren't set up for people like you. It must be very hard for you to come here every single day. I'm sorry no one really sees you. I'm sorry for all of that."

His face softened, and I could see tears welling up in his eyes. This tough kid was transformed into a vulnerable little boy before my eyes. I thought he was going to cry, and I hoped he wouldn't until he could find a safe place.

Softly, so softly I had to lean forward a little to hear him, he said, "No one's ever said that to me before, that I was bright."

And right there, I swear my heart broke.

At the end of the day, I would go home. But what about these lost satellites out of orbit? I'd probably never see this kid again. But he would be back the next day, and the next. I hoped it wasn't too late for him. And I hoped that whatever happened in his life, whether he continued on the road he was on, or somehow found the inner strength to discover his best self, that those words affirming his worth and value, his humanity, would stay in his heart. I hoped there would be others who would shine a light for him.


So simple… a story told and heard. Do I believe stories make a difference? Yes, to the listener and to the teller.
© Meg Gilman, 2004

No comments:

Post a Comment